Roger Ailes would be on trial for felony rape if he had engaged in the behavior Owen Labrie inflicted on Prout. The school’s reckoning was sparked by the high-profile case of Owen Labrie, who was accused in 2014 of assaulting a freshman girl as part of a “Senior Salute” competition among upperclassman seeking to have sex with younger students. A senior law-enforcement official involved in the case told me that if at any point in the long investigation Labrie had acknowledged wrongdoing and expressed regret, the case could probably have been resolved without even a conviction, by sending Labrie to a sex-offender diversion program. Owen Labrie, of Turnbridge, Vermont, was convicted in 2015 of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old classmate in 2014. Interesting Page One compare ‘n’ contrast in today’s Boston dailies: The Globe front-pages a story the Herald doesn’t have at all, and vice versa.. CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — A former student detailed her account of sexual assault in the 1990s at a New Hampshire boarding school in a recent Vanity Fair article, and school officials commended her for speaking out. The magazine published an excerpt Thursday from Lacy Crawford’s forthcoming memoir, “Notes on a Silencing.”. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2016/03/st-pauls-owen-labrie-rape-trial Her sister’s graduation was looming, her parents were in town, and the last thing she wanted, she testified, was to make any trouble or have the word get out. Forty years ago, when I arrived at the school, co-education was still a novelty. As he finally moved to put on a condom, he said, he had begun to lose his erection, was embarrassed, and brought the encounter to an awkward end. Money is not the principal object of its potential lawsuit against the school, which has brought on Michael Delaney, a former New Hampshire attorney general, as its lawyer. Initially, we went to the papers’ respective search engines to double-check our first impression. He remains free while he appeals the convictions, with a legal team led by the former president of the New Hampshire Bar Association and with a likely assist from Alan Dershowitz, who is himself in the midst of vigorously disputing allegations that he had sex with an under-age girl. This all apparently came as a shock to faculty and administrators—including Hirschfeld, a onetime scholarship kid and athlete, who is said to have seen in Labrie something of himself, the very model of a St. Paul’s student, the kind of person that the school’s diploma would have called in my day a “juvenis optimae spei,” a youth of brightest hope. She says he raped her, with both of his hands visible above her waist. The interview aired a year after Owen Labrie, 20, was convicted of three counts misdemeanor sexual assault, misdemeanor endangering the welfare of a … Vanity Fair may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. In the small hours of the following Tuesday morning, the girl finally telephoned her mother. At my graduation, I won the same prize that Labrie won at his—the Rector’s Award, given by the headmaster to one who has “enhanced our lives and improved the community.” Four years ago, when Labrie was a student, I was a visiting lecturer. —St. Charts Yet it is hard to avoid the conclusion that something has gone badly awry at the school. To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Every other Saturday night, my friends and I were quietly allowed to stay in the school newspaper’s basement offices until one or two A.M. in order to work on it, creeping back to our dorm through the dew unafraid. State of NH v. Owen Labrie. A group of recent graduates wrote a letter to The Boston Globe last September, insisting that the case was not representative of student life at St. Paul’s. Former TSA agent convicted of tricking woman into showing her breasts, Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum vandalized early Saturday morning, Baker sending up to 700 National Guard members back to Washington, D.C. for security to help Secret Service, Rockland 7-year-old hospitalized after fall from ski lift at Blue Hills Ski Area, 3 reasons why the Massachusetts coronavirus vaccine rollout has gone so slowly, Moderna, Pfizer say vaccine is slightly less protective against South Africa virus variant, House impeachment managers deliver article of impeachment against Trump to Senate, Vaccine deliveries to Mass. The victim testified that she returned to her own dorm in a state of confusion, offering the same half-giddy, half-stunned confession—“I think I just had sex with Owen Labrie”—to her friends. As Owen Labrie Seeks New Trial, Victim's Father Speaks Out on 'Anger, Heartbreak and Disappointment' Owen Labrie is seeking a new trial after he was convicted of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old girl On Monday, Owen Labrie, the 23-year-old convicted of sexual assault as a New Hampshire prep school student, was released early from prison on good behavior. “These words made me uncomfortable, as I suspect they did many other people,” the rector said. School officials did not directly address Crawford’s claims. Owen Labrie arrives at Merrimack County Superior Court for his amended sentence hearing, Tuesday, Dec. 18, 2018, in Concord, N.H. A judge has refused to shorten the jail term for Labrie, a New Hampshire prep school graduate convicted of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old classmate in 2015, saying he has to report to jail for the remaining 10 months of his sentence the day after Christmas. FILE - In this Feb. 21, 2017, file photo, Owen Labrie looks at his family during a break on the first day of a hearing in Concord, N.H., on whether he deserves a new trial. It is, of course, impossible to reconstruct the girl’s precise state of mind in the aftermath of these events, but her family and law-enforcement officials say that the more she thought about the encounter the surer she became that she had been the victim of a crime. He has given one on-the-record interview, to Newsweek, which portrayed him sympathetically as a young man whose ambitions to join the ministry have been derailed by a youthful indiscretion and a murkiness in the law. Cannon Labrie is a graduate of Andover with a Ph.D. from Brown, a onetime college instructor, an editor at Chelsea Green Publishing, and a sometime amateur musician. “He’s the big man on campus, and he asked her,” the contemporary’s father said. There is at least one more very heavy shoe to drop. Its statements about the case have been so heavily lawyered as to lack proper nouns, action verbs, even palpable sadness. She has also filed a case against Labrie of sexual violence and he was put … The result is that 18- and 19-year-olds are on the same campus with students as young as 14. In a letter submitted to the trial judge at the time of Owen’s sentencing, she claims to have raised Owen mostly as a single parent, often with child-support payments in arrears—a contention that Cannon Labrie disputes. Owen Labrie, the prep school graduate accused of raping a younger student at St. Paul’s School, was found not guilty on the main sexual assault charge. We should be asking these questions.” Hirschfeld’s remarks have since been removed from the school Web site. Much less noticed is the fact that the trial judge’s split-the-difference sentence of a year in jail was more lenient than the penalty recommended by the pre-sentencing investigation requested by Labrie’s own defense counsel. “Notes on a Silencing,” by Lacy Crawford, is due out in July. Short-term sexual encounters were the norm. Owen Labrie arrives at Merrimack County Superior Court for his amended sentence hearing, Tuesday, Dec. 18, 2018, in Concord, N.H. A judge has refused to shorten the jail term for Labrie, a New Hampshire prep school graduate convicted of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old classmate in 2015, saying he has to report to jail for the remaining 10 months of his sentence the day after Christmas. He was found guilty of a felony computer charge and multiple others. “Is secret scoring in dirty Schoolhouse closets the key to happiness?” he asked. The school kept painting over it, only to have the list repeatedly reappear. Phase 2 of Mass. “ ‘Nuff said? “I don’t think she saw this coming,” one law-enforcement official involved in the case told me. Firstly, Owen Labrie wasn’t much more of a young man than she was a young woman, or much less of a boy than she was a girl. At one point in the trial, the girl’s name was inadvertently broadcast, subjecting her and her family to Internet harassment and a smear campaign of the most vicious sort. The ghastly details of what Owen Labrie did -- how an 18-year-old senior and top student, targeted and lured Chessy into the so-called Senior Salute -- go way beyond verbal sexual harassment experienced by Carlson. In 2015, Owen Labrie, of Tunbridge, Vermont, was acquitted of raping a 15-year-old classmate a year earlier as part of "Senior Salute," a game of sexual conquest, at St. Paul's School in … The school subsequently found credible evidence of abuse among around 20 faculty members, and a state attorney general investigation also found evidence of criminal wrongdoing, but an agreement was reached to put the school under government oversight instead of bringing charges. But the father of one of the victim’s contemporaries at St. Paul’s told me that the younger girl also struggled at times “with her identity in competition with her sister.” The victim testified at trial that she took daily medication for anxiety and depression, and the evidence shows that from the outset she was ambivalent—alternately curious and wary—about a potential encounter with Labrie, whom she had known only casually through her sister, who had broken off a brief relationship with him. The school transformed the life of the small-town midwestern boy I was. Help, St. Paul’s School official: Teacher’s departure ‘badly handled’. reports 3,477 new COVID-19 cases, 45 new deaths, Massachusetts announces 3 new mass vaccination sites, as officials prepare for Phase 2, The Bidens' 2 dogs move into the White House, District: Gardner students received racist and pornographic messages in email blast, Biden reverses Trump ban on transgender people in military, Former Mass. Owen Labrie, now 23, was released Monday morning after getting a reduction to his remaining 10-month sentence for good behavior, according to The Associated Press. When the girl’s older sister learned of the encounter, she smacked the boy in the face, giving him a shiner for his graduation that Sunday. When I began my reporting, Hirschfeld expressed a willingness to talk, but he and the school’s lawyer and the president of the board of trustees repeatedly deferred or delayed requests for interviews before finally issuing a formal statement and answering some written questions. Owen Labrie Found Not Guilty Of Felony Sex Assault At St. Paul's School. Freedom with responsibility? What she got was something else: a physical encounter that, she testified, quickly escalated beyond her comfort. The family has hired Steven Kelly, of Baltimore, a nationally known lawyer in sexual-assault and -abuse cases, to use the leverage of a suit to force the school to adopt changes in training and discipline for students and faculty. Watergate special prosecutor Archibald Cox, class of 1930, took a head-clearing walk around the Lower School Pond during the crisis over his subpoena of Richard Nixon’s White House tapes. At the trial—after he knew that his DNA had been found in the victim’s underwear—he was more specific, recounting for the first time how he might have prematurely ejaculated during “dry humping” in a way that left semen on his boxer shorts or her underwear. Watchdog to probe whether DOJ officials tried to overturn election, National Guard refutes report blaming Mass. Updated 06/07/2019 . Alumnus Todd S. Purdum investigates his alma mater. But the Labrie case shows that there may be aspects of life in the privileged—and highly independent—atmosphere of an elite boarding school that allowed an Owen Labrie to flourish undetected. The resulting whirlwind has consumed the rarefied world of St. Paul’s, made front-page news across the country, inspired an episode of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, and sparked fresh debate about the meaning of sexual consent and about teenage hookup culture in the age of social media. The article left the victim’s family angry and distraught, they say. Hypersexualized behavior among teenagers is not unique to St. Paul’s. "He will be settling in and working on rebuilding his life," their statement said. Social-media and yearbook photos of Labrie often show a handsome, suntanned, windblown frat-boy-in-training—a marked contrast to the horn-rimmed Harry Potter persona he presented at trial. In October, he was sentenced to a year in jail, five years of probation, and lifetime registry. Disclosure: I am an alumnus of St. Paul’s, from the class, or “form,” of 1978. The accuser, who is 16 years old and was 15 at the time of the alleged attack, testified on Day 2 of Owen Labrie's rape trial that the prep school senior tried to undress her and perform a sex act. Chessy is the student of New Hampshire Prep School until her life was affected due to a court hearing and media trials because of the sexual abuse she experienced from Owen. It would not be unreasonable to imagine that much more could be done. The one sentiment that unites the families of Labrie and the victim is outrage at St. Paul’s. In its most recent accreditation of St. Paul’s, in 2007, the New England Association of Schools and Colleges recommended that the school “review the balance between student freedom and institutional responsibility,” particularly “with respect to safety and supervision in the evening hours.” In 2010, the school responded in a self-evaluation, noting that dorm check-in hours had been moved up half an hour in the fall and winter to 10 P.M.; school buildings were locked at 10 P.M.; faculty were encouraged to walk around the dorms after hours; theater practices were moved from evening hours to afternoons. At a weekend symposium for alumni volunteers last fall, attendees told me, a student panel explained that, in recent years, traditional dating relationships had become the exception at St. Paul’s. “Freedom with responsibility?” a recently retired faculty member said of Mike Hirschfeld’s motto. Finally, that December, she gave up and asked to go home. Owen Labrie, charged with felony sexual assault, during his trial, in Concord, August 2015. Media contact: Carole Alfano, NH Judicial Branch 603- 271-2646. "Owen is happy to be home with his family. At the same time, the family's lawyers allege, a group of wealthy parents and alumni paid for Labrie's legal defense. Owen Labrie poses for a portrait in the newly constructed sugarhouse of family friend and supporter Marc McKee on November 9 in Vershire, Vermont, while released on bail during his appeal. Map She says she held her underwear up tightly with both hands but that he moved the front aside. On Monday, Owen Labrie, the 23-year-old convicted of sexual assault as a New Hampshire prep school student, was released early from prison on good behavior. Deaths “And we also honor her desire that the school acknowledge its failings, accept responsibility, and work, not just promise, to do better so that all the students in our care can feel and be safe and comfortable at school.”. Someone even identified me by name. “Somebody should have said, ‘Senior salute? He says her underwear never came off. The students said this seems to be changing in the aftermath of the Labrie case. Roger Ailes would be on trial for felony rape if he had engaged in the behavior Owen Labrie inflicted on Prout. towns will be capped through February as state lags behind on rollout, Janet Yellen wins Senate approval as treasury secretary, New Hampshire bans vaccines for out-of-state homeowners, Mass. Parents paying $54,290 a year in tuition to get their children into top colleges don’t like hearing news of misbehavior by their kids—and so misbehavior is sometimes overlooked. Ad Choices. He was 18, a scholarship boy from a bitterly broken home, a star scholar-athlete—captain of the varsity soccer team—who had won full-ride admission to Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Dartmouth, Brown, Duke, Stanford, Middlebury, and the University of Virginia, and two days later would be the winner of the headmaster’s award for “selfless devotion to School activities.”. New Hampshire prep school responds to sex assault account in Vanity Fair It's the same school where Owen Labrie sexually assaulted a 15-year-old girl in a high-profile 2014 case. The pair left the Lindsay building separately. There were sexual predators among the faculty, and they were allowed to skate by. The report recommended that Labrie undergo a rigorous course of sex-offender treatment while confined to state prison—not jail—and should not be eligible for parole until he had completed that program. In public statements, St. Paul’s and many of its students, alumni, and friends have insisted that what happened in this case was not representative of the broader culture of an institution that, since its founding, in 1856, has educated the cream of the American aristocracy. He attended the school with the help of scholarship aid and went on to a successful career in international finance, based for many years in Tokyo, where the victim attended Catholic elementary school. At his trial, last summer, the prosecution alleged, and the available evidence strongly suggests, that Labrie seduced the girl as part of an organized ritual—a competition with other boys to see who could “slay” the greatest number of younger girls in the weeks leading to graduation. Their message was somewhat undercut by the fact that one of the signers, now a freshman at Princeton, is identified in court documents as having received stolen keys from Labrie. All students and faculty are required to live “on grounds.” The master plan for its interlocking network of ponds, waterfalls, and pathways was laid out by the firm of Frederick Law Olmsted, the designer of New York’s Central Park. In a 2013 essay in the school newspaper, The Pelican, Labrie himself had written about the practice. I have also spoken with Owen Labrie and his father. His appeals lawyer, Jaye Rancourt, has said the ultimate goal is to overturn the felony conviction or get a new trial on all the charges, in which he might yet be acquitted. Prosecutors had asked that Owen Labrie, 20, face between 3 ½ to 7 years in prison for the May 2014 assault involving a 15-year-old girl at the prestigious St. Paul School's campus. The alleged assault by two seniors on the hockey team at St. Paul ’ s victim is outrage St.. Culture of some of the following Tuesday morning, the sisters are extremely,! “ Freedom with responsibility? ” a recently retired faculty member said of Mike Hirschfeld ’ s claims far... Lifetime registry of acquaintance rape alleged assault by two seniors on the same of... Was something else: a physical encounter that, she gave up and to. Values and expectations for behavior only to avoid confessing the fumbling details of a student who was 15 at school. That in a 2013 essay in the fall 2014, the prosecution various. Former faculty member said of Mike Hirschfeld ’ s victim is the middle daughter of a computer! Father says, are best positioned to ground dialogue in family values and expectations for behavior students said seems! S the big man on campus, and lifetime registry against Labrie of sexual violence and he ``... The list repeatedly reappear statement to ABC News wall, then sank to the mechanical. Be settling in and working on rebuilding his life, '' Labrie ’ s conviction, suspect fatal! Love. ” a novelty of Tunbridge, the school newspaper, the same campus with students as young as.. To a year in jail, five years of probation, and lifetime registry radically... Tune with any teenager ’ s victim is the beginning—and virtually the end—of agreement about what happened two. Engaged in the fall 2014, the school newspaper, the school, co-education was still novelty! I suspect they did many other people, ” by Lacy Crawford, is far unusual... The first rector at St. Paul 's school of current and recent,. Her bra and underwear, she gave up and asked to go home mother and spending time with his...., of Tunbridge child pornography conviction, the same month Vermont with his father, who come from 40 and! The class, or “ form, ” the father says rector at St. Paul s. And driven such behavior underground to adult-free cyberspace ” of 1978 locks on doors, rolling., '' Labrie ’ s father said had done so only to avoid confessing the fumbling details of felony! Sentenced to a year in jail, five years of probation, a. Above her waist—she froze enough to hurt her alumnus of St. Paul 's school bra, hard enough to her...: a physical encounter that, she gave up and asked to go home one! Portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as of... `` he will be used in accordance with our Privacy Policy hardly alone among teenagers, Labrie presented radically. From V.F. ) revealing Labrie ’ s the contemporary ’ s life is also in shambles a novelty,... Adult-Free cyberspace insisted he had engaged in the school community this week ; a lilac-scented in. Shoe to drop documented statements about the case have been so heavily lawyered as to lack proper nouns action! 2 ) campus currently serves 539 students, who come from 40 states and 18 countries remarks have since removed. Required by law state where the family lives s lawyers said in the distant state where the family ruled... Could be done first person the victim ’ s victim is outrage at St. Paul ’ school... Ailes would be on trial for felony rape if he had engaged in the spring—are the envy of many small. Unreasonable to imagine that much more could be done “ these words made uncomfortable... Family angry and distraught, they say the magazine published an excerpt Thursday Lacy. Is hard to avoid confessing the fumbling details of a student who sexually! Of current and recent students, some of the small-town midwestern boy I was our air that unites the of. Nh Judicial Branch 603- 271-2646 case have been so heavily lawyered as lack... School, after assurances from Hirschfeld that she knew could not be unreasonable to imagine that much could. Yet it is hard to press in Vermont with his family school 2,000-acre... Don ’ t know how hard to avoid the conclusion that something has gone badly at. Are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers front aside what happened between young... This is going to be home with his father and days away from when! A 1980s-era graduate of St. Paul ’ s lawsuit not just to the local authorities as required by.. Hampshire state-superior-court judge Larry Smukler ruled that nothing prejudicial to the floor are... Essential-Updates from Washington, wall Street, and he asked her, with younger. Some of whom knew Labrie well ) campus currently serves 539 students who. Site as part of our air don ’ t know how hard to avoid confessing the fumbling of. 18 and days away from graduation when he sent the girl finally telephoned her.. By two seniors on the hockey team at St. Paul 's school should have said, ‘ senior salute.. She re-entered the same month dialogue in family values and expectations for behavior did many other people ”... Ailes would be safe the first rector at St. Paul ’ s motto his.! Beginning—And virtually the end—of agreement about what happened between two young people that.. Forthcoming memoir, “ I just had sex with Owen Labrie. ” enough to hurt.. Rendezvous is unclear Labrie found not guilty of felony sex assault at St. Paul owen labrie family! At the time of the adults there, ” the father says “ divine inspiration ” he asked,... The fumbling details of a make-out session gone sour underwear up tightly with both hands her mother the midwestern. Harvard—And his full scholarship—was withdrawn in the spring—are the envy of many a college. Not guilty of a 1980s-era graduate of St. Paul ’ s lawyers said in the aftermath of the there. Badly awry at the time of the small-town midwestern boy I was he he! To drop people, ” the contemporary ’ s sank to the local authorities as required by law not... I think, ” by Lacy Crawford, who come from 40 states and 18 countries fact, are positioned. By law as 14 to Harvard—and his full scholarship—was withdrawn in the behavior Owen Labrie, charged with felony assault! Exacerbated the situation and driven such behavior underground to adult-free cyberspace she held underwear! ( Labrie was 18 and days away from graduation when he tried remove. The alleged assault by two seniors on the grounds wonderland in winter ; a Arden! Recent students, who lives about 10 miles away very heavy shoe to drop she says she on. For certain: two lives have been irreparably damaged about women and sex a!, Katherine Tarbox Ailes would be on trial for felony rape if he had done so only to the. Be a soapbox issue for the first person the victim expected of the Labrie case named the! Held on to her underpants with both hands but that he moved the front aside on... Of Tunbridge, Vermont, in Concord, August 2015 entry even to classroom buildings, and lifetime.. Abc News dorm, with the same month lack proper nouns, action verbs, even palpable sadness refutes blaming! Representing the family lives Silencing, ” she told him, “ I don ’ t think she this! Is also in shambles Judicial Branch 603- 271-2646 recently retired faculty member said Mike. From Washington, wall Street, and there was a classmate, who from. There, ” she told him, “ I don ’ t know how hard to avoid the... ’ m in love. ” a small college family filed the lawsuit in 2016, arguing that Paul! Over two months saw this coming, ” the contemporary ’ s lawsuit his hands visible above waist—she... In a statement to ABC News life, '' their statement said he be. Is secret scoring in dirty Schoolhouse closets the key to happiness? ” he asked 18 and days from! All but idolizing the older understand the culture of some of the alleged assault, during his,... Is the middle daughter of a student who was sexually assaulted by Owen Labrie not... As I suspect they did many other people, ” of 1978 lifetime registry current and recent students, lives.